> Zed Book Club / Denial

Clouds, Photo: David Levenson/Getty Images; Gastown, Vancouver, Photo: artran /Getty Images; Denial, Beverley McLauchlin

> Bookshelf

Denial

Beverley McLachlin's second legal thriller, starring indefatigable defence lawyer Jilly Truitt, hinges on a moral conundrum ripped from the pages of the retired Supreme Court judge's personal and professional life / BY Kim Honey / September 17th, 2021


Ask Beverley McLachlin how many judgments she’s written for the Supreme Court of Canada, and you can hear the shrug in her voice.

“There is a statistic on that,” the retired legal eagle says in a phone interview from her home in Vancouver. “People keep citing it to me and I never remember.”

That number, according to her mentor bio on the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation website, is 442 opinions, although she participated in more than 2,000 decisions.

No doubt she has gone through a forest of legal pads in 28 years on the bench – the last 17 as the country’s first female Chief Justice – but the judge, who retired in 2017, has not put down her quill and capped her inkpot. Note that “prolific” is one word often used to describe her career.

At 78, McLachlin has just published Denial, her second legal thriller about heroine Jilly Truitt, the indefatigable criminal defence lawyer introduced in 2018’s Full Disclosure. In between the two novels, McLachlan published her 2019 memoir, Truth Be Told, which won the $25,000 Shaughnessy Cohen Prize for political writing.

Denial

 

In the first pages of Denial, Truitt is asked by a pillar of the Vancouver legal community to represent his wife, Vera Quentin, who is accused of murdering her cancer-stricken mother in a mercy killing. Vera suffered from post-partum depression in the past and is now taking medication for anxiety, “marinating in my customized pharmaceutical brine,” she tells Truitt. “Pills and pills and pills. Happy pills, relax pills.”

That, plus the fact that Vera has already fired two lawyers because they advised her to take a plea bargain and she would rather go to jail than admit one iota of guilt, makes the case “an absolute loser,” Truitt’s law partner says.

When Truitt interviews Vera, who was in the house the night her mother died from a lethal injection of morphine, something is off. But this perfect wife, with her velvety voice, silky hair and pale complexion, captivates the defence lawyer, who starts to believe Vera would never give in to her mother’s request to help end her life. Then again, Vera’s denial could be rooted in self-delusion, or, as McLachlin writes, “the brain playing tricks.” Much to her partner’s disgust, Truitt takes the case.

Denial is a phenomenon McLachlin witnessed in court as a lawyer and a judge. “People often come into a lawyer – not infrequently, shall I say – and they say, ‘this is my story, and I’m totally innocent. I haven’t done anything wrong. I’m the victim of something.’ And then as you get deeper into the case, you realize there are these layers and that, in order to live with themselves, perhaps subconsciously, they’ve erased certain aspects of the story.”

That’s what makes a criminal case a natural fit for a thriller. The defence lawyer is part investigator, because they have to find a way to plant a seed of reasonable doubt in the minds of a jury or a judge. If you believe the client is not guilty, you have to figure out who else could have done it. Also, “that’s what makes it fun,” McLachlin adds.

As Truitt says in the novel: “No matter how open and shut the case seems: no one saw Vera Quentin put the needle in her mother’s arm.”

In Denial, McLachlin raises moral issues drawn from her personal and professional life: the grey areas in Medical Assistance in Dying; at what point mental illness becomes a defence; how powerless women are painted as unstable when they assert independence from controlling men; and there’s even a subplot about sex work and the trafficking of young girls.

McLachlin writes from the heart in a scene where Vera tells Truitt her mother’s bladder cancer was “the slow suffering kind,” and asked for a lethal dose of morphine. Vera says, “I couldn’t. Even in that, I failed her.”

The same scenario played out at McLachlin’s home in 1988, when her husband of 20 years, Rory McLachlin, was dying of cancer. In Truth Be Told, McLachlin says he was in great physical and psychological pain, and asked her to help him die with a morphine overdose.

Beverley McLauchlin
Beverley McLachlin, the retired Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada, mines her personal and professional life in her second legal thriller, “Denial.” Photo: Jean-Marc Carisse

 

“But this, in my heart, I knew I could not do,” she writes. “Because it was against the law. Because I could not physically bring myself to do it.” Just four years later, McLachlin was on the Supreme Court of Canada when Vancouver Island resident Sue Rodriguez, who had Lou Gehrig’s disease, appealed a decision denying her assisted suicide. Rodriguez lost the case, but McLachlin was one of the dissenting voices, arguing that the assisted-suicide ban violated Rodriguez’s guarantee of liberty under section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In 2015, McLachlin presided over a similar case, Carter v Canada, when, in a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court struck down the criminalization of assisted suicide.

Although Denial wades into more murky territory, such as advance requests for assisted suicide from people who have been diagnosed with dementia, for example, she doesn’t prescribe a solution. She only raises the questions.

“In a novel, you’re not didactic. You’re not saying this is the way it should be,” McLachlin says. “But you’re trying to present different perspectives and different people and explore the moral conundrum.”

In this book, some characters are up to some old tricks. Truitt’s former mentor, Crown prosecutor Cy Kenge, is still trying to double-cross her. Her deadbeat father Vincent Trussardi, whom she defended in Full Disclosure after he was accused of murdering his wife, is MIA, again. And she still has feelings for her ex, who is dating someone else. Of course there is a murder, and of course someone is out to get Truitt.

Writing legal thrillers is a challenge because McLachlin has to keep the plot moving, and that means condensing legal procedures that often take weeks or months in real life – and, she concedes, can bore the pants off a layperson – into pithy passages.

She doesn’t work from an outline, but starts with “ a problem or conundrum” and lets the plot unspool from there.

“I have a general idea of how it might end, because I think you need to know or you wouldn’t put in all the work to get there. But then it always surprises me and something different happens,” she says, adding, “that’s one of the real pleasures of writing fiction.”

McLachlin mentions she’s working on another book, but she’s as tight-lipped as a judge facing a media scrum. When asked what’s next, she says she’s playing with a couple of ideas. So she’s thinking about it? “I’m thinking about it,” she allows. “At this point in my life every day is a gift. I’m 78 years old. I’d love to do [another book], because it’s a lot of fun and I definitely will move on.”

Next parry: Will it be another Jilly Truitt book?

“Probably.”

So she is hedging her bets? “I have to hedge that, because I just don’t know how this idea I have will be best expressed. It’s a very preliminary stage here, but I’d love to work with Jilly again.”

At the pace McLachlin writes, fans shouldn’t have to wait too long to find out if Jilly Truitt takes on another seemingly unwinnable case.

THE SCROLL

Prince Harry’s ‘Spare’ Continues to Break Worldwide RecordsThe book also seems to have put a dent in the popularity of members of the Royal Family — including the Prince and Princess of Wales.


Prince Harry’s Memoir Breaks U.K. Sales Record On First Day of ReleaseThe publisher of the new memoir, 'Spare", says it had sold 400,000 copies so far across hardback, e-book and audio formats.


Barack Obama’s Favourite Books of 2022The former U.S. president’s 13 titles include Canadians Emily St. John Mandel and Kate Beaton, as well as tomes from Michelle Obama, George Saunders and Jennifer Egan


Here are the 5 Books on Bill Gates’ Holiday Reading ListThe billionaire philanthropist is giving hundreds of copies to little libraries around the world


Sheila Heti and Eli Baxter Among 2022 Governor General’s Literary Award WinnersToronto writer Sheila Heti took home the fiction award for 'Pure Colour,' a novel the GG peer assessment committee called "a work of genius."


Suzette Mayr Wins $100,000 Scotiabank Giller Prize for ‘The Sleeping Car Porter’The 2022 Giller Prize jury called Mayr's novel "alive and immediate — and eerily contemporary."


Writers’ Trust of Canada Awards: Authors Nicholas Herring, Dan Werb Nab Top PrizesThe Writers' Trust of Canada awards amounted to a combined monetary prize value of $270,000.


Bob Dylan Releases ‘The Philosophy of Modern Song,’ a Book of Essays Dissecting 66 Influential SongsIn his new book, Bob Dylan offers up both critique and historical insight into various musical recordings of the last century by a variety of popular artists.


Prince Harry’s Memoir ‘Spare’ Will Be Published in January 2023The long-awaited memoir will tell with "raw unflinching honesty" Prince Harry's journey from "trauma to healing", his publisher said on Thursday.


Sri Lankan Author Shehan Karunatilaka Wins 2022 Booker PrizeKarunatilaka won the prestigious prize on Monday for his second novel ‘The Seven Moons of Maali Almeida’, about a dead war photographer on a mission in the afterlife.


Canadian Council for the Arts Reveals Governor General’s Literary Awards FinalistsThe finalists for the Governor General's Literary Awards spotlight books in both the English and French language, as well as translated works.


New Penguin Random House Award Named After Michelle Obama Will Honour High School WritersMichelle Obama Award for Memoir will provide a $10,000 college scholarship to a graduating public school senior based on their autobiographical submission.


French Author Annie Ernaux, 82, Becomes First French Woman to Win Nobel Prize for LiteratureThe author said, of winning, that "I was very surprised ... I never thought it would be on my landscape as a writer."


Hilary Mantel, Award-Winning British Author of ‘Wolf Hall’ Trilogy, Dies at 70Wolf Hall, published in 2009, and its sequel Bring Up the Bodies, released three years later, both won the Booker Prize, an unprecedented win for two books in the same trilogy and making Mantel the first woman to win the award twice.


Prince William “Cannot Forgive” Prince Harry, According to ‘The New Royals’ Author Katie NichollPrince William “just cannot forgive his brother,” according to Katie Nicholl, author of 'The New Royals: Queen Elizabeth’s Legacy and the Future of the Crown.'


Five Finalists Announced for Hilary Weston Writers’ Trust Prize for NonfictionThe winner — to be announced on November 2 — will take home the annual $60,000 prize.


Peter Straub, Bestselling American Horror Writer, Dies at 79Friend and co-author Stephen King has said the author's 1979 book, "Ghost Story," is his favourite horror novel.


Rawi Hage, Billy-Ray Belcourt and Sheila Heti Make the 2022 Scotiabank Giller Prize Long ListThe jury read 138 books to choose 14 titles for the long list, one of which will win the $100,000 prize, one of the richest in Canadian literature


Salman Rushdie, Novelist Who Drew Death Threats, Is Stabbed at New York LectureThe Indian-born novelist who was ordered killed by Iran in 1989 because of his writing, was attacked before giving a talk on artistic freedom.


Raymond Briggs, Creator of Beloved Children’s Tale ‘The Snowman’, Dies at 88First published in 1978, the pencil crayon-illustrated wordless picture book sold more than 5.5 million copies around the world while a television adaption became a Christmas favourite in Britain and was nominated for an Oscar.


Canadian Author Emily St. John Mandel Makes Barack Obama’s 2022 Summer Reading ListObama's list includes everything from fiction to books on politics, cultural exploration and basketball.


Canadian Author Rebecca Eckler to Launch RE:books Publishing House Focused on Female Authors and Fun ReadsThe former National Post columnist says her tagline is ‘What’s read is good, and what’s good is read.’”


Brian Thomas Isaac’s “All the Quiet Places” wins $5,000 Indigenous Voices AwardThe B.C. author, a retired bricklayer, drew on his childhood growing up on the Okanagan Indian reserve for his coming-of-age story set in 1956


Canadian-American Author Ruth Ozeki Wins Women’s Book Prize for “The Book of Form and Emptiness”The UK judges said her fourth novel, inspired in part by the Vancouver Public Library, contained "sparkling writing, warmth, intelligence, humour and poignancy."


The Bill Gates Summer Reading List Includes a Sci-Fi Novel On Gender Inequality Suggested by His DaughterBill Gates' summer reading list includes fiction and non-fiction titles that cover gender equality, political polarization and climate change.


American novelist Joshua Cohen wins the Pulitzer Prize for fiction for “The Netanyahus”The 2022 Pulitzer prizes include this satirical look at identity politics, focused on the father of former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, at a crucial time in the Jewish state’s history


Margaret Atwood, Alice Munro Among Canadian Authors Recognized in Commemorative Reading List Marking Queen’s Platinum JubileeThe authors are among six Canadian scribes included on the The Big Jubilee Read list.


Queen Elizabeth II’s Aide Reveals Details of Life in Royal Pandemic Lockdown in New Addition to BookAngela Kelly, who's worked for the Queen for 20 years, discusses everything from cutting the Queen's hair to "the light and laughter that was shared ... even in the darkest moments."


New Leonard Cohen Story Collection, ‘A Ballet of Lepers,’ Set for October ReleaseThe collection features a novel, short stories and a radio play written between 1956 and 1961.


Archived Letters Reveal How Toni Morrison Helped MacKenzie Scott Meet Future Husband Jeff BezosBezos hired Scott at the hedge fund where he worked after receiving a recommendation from Morrison. Shortly thereafter, the pair married and Scott helped Bezos launch Amazon.


Prince Harry’s Memoir is Set to Rock the MonarchyFriends say the California-based royal got a million-pound book deal to write "an intimate take on his feeling about the family."


European Jewish Congress Asks Publisher to Pull Anne Frank BookThe Congress says 'The Betrayal of Anne Frank' has "deeply hurt the memory of Anne Frank, as well as the dignity of the survivors and the victims of the Holocaust."


Canadian Author Details Anne Frank Cold-Case Investigation That Named Surprise Suspect in Her Family’s Betrayal in New BookAhead of the 75th anniversary of the publication of Frank's 'The Diary of a Young Girl' in June, a team that included a retired FBI agent and around 20 historians, criminologists and data specialists identified a relatively unknown figure as a leading suspect in revealing her family's hideout.


Man Who Tricked Authors Into Handing Over Unpublished Manuscripts Arrested by FBI in New YorkFilippo Bernardini, an employee of a well known publication house, has been arrested for stealing hundreds of unpublished manuscripts.


Hollywood Legend Betty White Has a Last Laugh in New Biographic Comic BookThe creators of the biographical comic book have released similar books about Hollywood legends like Carrie Fisher, Lucille Ball, David Bowie and Elizabeth Taylor.


Barack Obama Reveals His List of Books That Left “A Lasting Impression” in 2021Obama's favourite 2021 reads include two-time Pulitzer Prize-winning author Colson Whitehead's 'Harlem Shuffle' and 'Klara and the Sun,' by Nobel Prize-winning author Kazuo Ishiguro


“Interview With the Vampire” Author Anne Rice Dies at 80 — Tributes Pour in From Stuart Townsend and OthersThe author, who was best known for her work in gothic fiction, died on Saturday evening as a result of complications from a stroke.


Norma Dunning wins $25,000 Governor General’s English fiction prize for ‘Tainna’The Edmonton-based Inuk writer explores themes of displacement, loneliness and spirituality in six short stories


Omar El Akkad wins $100,000 Giller prize for “What Strange Paradise”The former Globe and Mail reporter, who published "American War" to acclaim in 2017, tackles the global migrant refugee crisis in his second novel


South African Author Damon Galgut Wins the Booker Prize For ‘The Promise’Galgut received nominations for his 2003 and 2010 works before finally taking home the prize this year. 


Hollywood Legend Paul Newman Discusses Life, Acting and Aging Gracefully in Newly Discovered MemoirPublishers of the newly discovered memoir say the Hollywood legend wrote the book in the 1980s in response to the relentless media attention he received during that time.


Here’s What You Need to Know About the Toronto International Festival of AuthorsDirector Roland Gulliver lands in Toronto to open his second, much-expanded virtual festival with more than 200 events


Tanzanian Novelist Gurnah Wins 2021 Nobel Prize in Literature for Depicting the Impact of Colonialism and Refugee StoriesGurnah, 72, is only the second writer from sub-Saharan Africa to win one of the world's most prestigious literary awards


Miriam Toews Garners Third Giller Prize Nomination for “Fight Night” after Shortlist AnnouncedSophomore efforts from novelists Omar El Akkad and Jordan Tannahill join debut books from Cheluchi Onyemelukwe-Onuobia and Angélique Lalonde


Tina Brown’s New Book, ‘The Palace Papers’, Covers the Royal Family’s Reinvention After Diana’s Tragic DeathTina Brown's sequel to her 2007 release 'The Diana Chronicles' is set to hit shelves April 12, 2022. 


Audible.ca Releases Andrew Pyper’s Exclusive Audiobook “Oracle” For New Plus Catalogue LaunchThe thriller about a psychic FBI detective is one of 12,000 titles now available for free to members


Barack Obama and Bruce Springsteen to Release Book Based On Their “Renegades” PodcastThe new book will feature a collection of candid, intimate and entertaining conversations


Prince Harry Will Publish a Memoir in Late 2022Harry says he's writing the book "not as the prince I was born but as the man I have become."


> STAY UP TO DATE

Sign Up for the Weekly Book Club Newsletter